i10 v/s A-star

Now both of these cars are from the 2 leading car manufacturers in India. Both are in the same category... further more they are evenly matched to add to the fun.
So I ask my fellow members to award the winner

Hyundai i10:Hyundai's small wonder the i10 is a car that has done extremely well in the market powered by the 1.1L iRDE and 1.2L kappa the car has a light and zippy factor to it. Also its the 1st car of its segment to have a Euro-5 ready emission norms. Its a family car in all, its ideal for the man with a family comprising his wife and 2 kids. Also due to its small size its rather manouverable around the city, fuel-efficiency is implied. All-over its a very good package(I mean SRK would'nt endorse it for nothing). So go ahead catch the i. :drive2:

Maruti Suzuki A-star:A car in a class of its own. It was designed with the modern couple in mind who drive on their own, which explains the uncomfortable rear seat. However powered by the 1L KB-10 engine which is rather peppy to say the least, it offers a phenomenal pick up, also in the drivers seat you feel like riding a volvo bus. The car is more like a bachelor's car, ideal to take the girl next door out on a date in. Its modern looks lends to it a subtle boyish charm. When the Company said it wouldnt stop @ nothing they werent kidding, the only thing which can stop this car is either a brick wall or a flat tyre.


Hyundai i10..."Catch the i"

Maruti Suzuki A-Star..."Stop @ nothing"

I think now you should add the Ritz too in the list.


RoadRocket

1st let the car be launched and then see what category it belongs to then ill edit as per requirement

Voted for i10
It's proven best in performance, efficiency, quality and everything!

i have voted for the i10, the A star looks bad. the only marutis i have liked in the styling dept. are swift & new vitara.

I voted for A-star, because i10 acts as a small car when it has even four persons on board. Its ride is bad when loaded up. Moreover A-star is good in many aspects, except boot space and rear seat, which i don't need.

NOTE: car-o-static, You already know that you can use "EDIT" option in your posts to add further content, So kindly refrain from multiposting in future otherwise your posts will be deleted without any such warning.Thanks.

VT

i10 for me.Anyday better than A-star, looks, fit,finish space all.

Hey CC, Do you really mean A-star is better than i10? Then you got to TD both the cars before commenting on that.

A-star has got just 3 pot cylinders which is never equal to 16v DOHC of i10 :)

Voted for i10, Just love my car :D

There is no bias here, since i owned it, A-star is really a underperformer when compared to i10 & even Reviews tell that !

My vote goes to the I10. Its a better car than the A-star and also looks much better.

i voted for i10
i just love i10 and A-Star looks feeble compared to i10!

My vote too goes for Hyundai i10.
It has better looks than of A-Star, More spacious(atleast than A-Star which is very cramped from rear),Also its proven Kappa engine. :winkthumb:

VT

I too voted for i10!

RoadRocket

I'm the odd one out in the poll :lol!:

zinam wrote:Hey CC, Do you really mean A-star is better than i10? Then you got to TD both the cars before commenting on that.

A-star has got just 3 pot cylinders which is never equal to 16v DOHC of i10 :)

Voted for i10, Just love my car :D

There is no bias here, since i owned it, A-star is really a underperformer when compared to i10 & even Reviews tell that !

I didn't mean the engine actually, it was the suspension setup. It was too soft for our large adults(only less suspension travel left out with all the load on board), which A-star is better. And also I test drove the 1.1l irde engine only, it was a real bad performer when loaded up. I never driven i10 kappa with persons at the back, so couldn't comment on that. Though engine has been changed, suspension should be the same i guess.